Grammar fail or not, I don't hold much of an opinion. We already know she pulled an epic character trait fail for the vampires.

-Spike- wrote:

Grammar fail or not, I don't hold much of an opinion. We already know she pulled an epic character trait fail for the vampires.

I guess that depends on how you like your Vampire: the common Table Vampire or the Sparkling variant...

But it's what I thought the be one of the short comings of 'twilight', it's simply a ridiculous scene.
The nigh rape scene was completly uncalled for and pushed what would have been a High-Shool romance in Teenage-Bodice-Ripper territory, personally I would have dropped that scene from the book, too.

Unfortunately the other two books simply lack a comprehensible plot.
Eclipse had a little more of that again than New Moon did it and brought the story more or less to a close, not sure why she thought it to be a good idea to write Breaking Dawn on top.

The only thing that really grates on me is the whole imprinting idea, that's just not a trait you should give to a character that is supposed to be the good guy.

Last edited by Daninsky (2008-11-27 08:56:56)

-Spike- wrote:

...Is Jacob supposed to be the good guy? Because from what I've read, it sounds like she's trying to destroy him complety.

If yoy want me to give some away, well, read the next segment:

He's in love with Bella and hates Vampires (Aka - Edward) and wants to see him dead because he thinks that vampires are only blood sucking 'parasites' - nothing more. So he tries to destroy Edward and get to Bella himself.

Well, everybody that wants to see Edward dead counts as a good guy somehow, no? :p

*Kinda Spoilerish!*


Seriously though, Bella does fall in love with Jacob, too, in a way.
And even after he he becomes a pushy, demanding sod that force-kisses her (Stephenie must have been very fond of reading Bodice Rippers) she still holds to him (though she doesn't love him the way she loves Edward and blah, blah). And yeah, in essence the whole Weregang is part of the good guys.
Things become really disturbing in Breaking Dawn when she sets up Jacob as child molester, because c'mon how else does she think this will work out?

I'm pretty sure that the only person besides Stephenie Meyer to think that end to Jacobs story to have been a good idea is Woody Allen, that pervert married his own daughter after all...

Last edited by Daninsky (2008-11-28 06:34:10)

yeah true same here lol

Man if u saw bella in twilight the movie she look hot in her panties.................... sorry got lost lol

Freddy wrote:

Man if u saw bella in twilight the movie she look hot in her panties.................... sorry got lost lol

And every guy would think that, naturally

Fftt!!

Vancariad wrote:

Erg, the ONLY thing remotely good about Twilight are the werewolves and even THEY are bad...sorry Twilighters.

...There aren't even werewolves IN Twilight!!! You have to waste your life reading the first one and get lost halfway through New Moon to find them!!!

So you don't even really know what you are argumenting against? :p

Daninsky wrote:

So you don't even really know what you are argumenting against? :p

I'm way past the halfway mark!   And I've looke up the synopsis online, and I think I have some valid arguements.

Well I think I've put up a fair fight on this forum already.